Welcome to Software Development on Codidact!
Will you help us build our independent community of developers helping developers? We're small and trying to grow. We welcome questions about all aspects of software development, from design to code to QA and more. Got questions? Got answers? Got code you'd like someone to review? Please join us.
Post History
Two types of software recommendation When someone says "software recommendation" they may mean one of two quite different things, for which the answer to your question will be different. Recommen...
#2: Post edited
by
trichoplax
·
2025-04-28T19:16:45Z (about 1 month ago)
Improve consistency of example with request
- ## Two types of software recommendation
- When someone says "software recommendation" they may mean one of two quite different things, for which the answer to your question will be different.
- ### Recommendations for users
- If someone asks for software that they can use to do something unrelated to software development, such as editing an image using a graphical user interface, this is outside the scope of Software Development Codidact.
- If anyone would like to be able to ask such questions, they can propose a new community on [Codidact Proposals](https://proposals.codidact.com/categories/66).
- ### Recommendations for developers
- If someone asks for software that they can use in the course of software development, such as a recommendation of a library or some existing software to learn from or adapt, I would expect this to be outside the scope of the Q&A category. Although answering a question about how to fix a specific problem may lead to answers that happen to include a recommended library or existing software to adapt, asking directly for a recommendation does not seem a good fit for the Q&A category.
- However, new categories can easily be added. For example, we already have the [Code Reviews category](https://software.codidact.com/categories/44) where requests for feedback on code can be posted, even though these would be off topic in the Q&A category. If anyone would like to see a new category for software development related recommendation questions, they can suggest this in a Meta question so the community can discuss whether they would like to see this and what its scope would be.
For example, there would need to be a decision on whether such a category would only allow recommendation requests for libraries, or also allow asking about recommended IDEs and other development tools.
- ## Two types of software recommendation
- When someone says "software recommendation" they may mean one of two quite different things, for which the answer to your question will be different.
- ### Recommendations for users
- If someone asks for software that they can use to do something unrelated to software development, such as editing an image using a graphical user interface, this is outside the scope of Software Development Codidact.
- If anyone would like to be able to ask such questions, they can propose a new community on [Codidact Proposals](https://proposals.codidact.com/categories/66).
- ### Recommendations for developers
- If someone asks for software that they can use in the course of software development, such as a recommendation of a library or some existing software to learn from or adapt, I would expect this to be outside the scope of the Q&A category. Although answering a question about how to fix a specific problem may lead to answers that happen to include a recommended library or existing software to adapt, asking directly for a recommendation does not seem a good fit for the Q&A category.
- However, new categories can easily be added. For example, we already have the [Code Reviews category](https://software.codidact.com/categories/44) where requests for feedback on code can be posted, even though these would be off topic in the Q&A category. If anyone would like to see a new category for software development related recommendation questions, they can suggest this in a Meta question so the community can discuss whether they would like to see this and what its scope would be.
- For example, there would need to be a decision on whether such a category would only allow recommendation requests for libraries and example code to learn from, or also allow asking about recommended IDEs and other development tools.
#1: Initial revision
by
trichoplax
·
2025-04-28T19:13:36Z (about 1 month ago)
## Two types of software recommendation When someone says "software recommendation" they may mean one of two quite different things, for which the answer to your question will be different. ### Recommendations for users If someone asks for software that they can use to do something unrelated to software development, such as editing an image using a graphical user interface, this is outside the scope of Software Development Codidact. If anyone would like to be able to ask such questions, they can propose a new community on [Codidact Proposals](https://proposals.codidact.com/categories/66). ### Recommendations for developers If someone asks for software that they can use in the course of software development, such as a recommendation of a library or some existing software to learn from or adapt, I would expect this to be outside the scope of the Q&A category. Although answering a question about how to fix a specific problem may lead to answers that happen to include a recommended library or existing software to adapt, asking directly for a recommendation does not seem a good fit for the Q&A category. However, new categories can easily be added. For example, we already have the [Code Reviews category](https://software.codidact.com/categories/44) where requests for feedback on code can be posted, even though these would be off topic in the Q&A category. If anyone would like to see a new category for software development related recommendation questions, they can suggest this in a Meta question so the community can discuss whether they would like to see this and what its scope would be. For example, there would need to be a decision on whether such a category would only allow recommendation requests for libraries, or also allow asking about recommended IDEs and other development tools.