Welcome to Software Development on Codidact!
Will you help us build our independent community of developers helping developers? We're small and trying to grow. We welcome questions about all aspects of software development, from design to code to QA and more. Got questions? Got answers? Got code you'd like someone to review? Please join us.
Comments on Should asking about book recommendations directly connected to software development be on-topic?
Parent
Should asking about book recommendations directly connected to software development be on-topic?
Context
We have recently received a suggestion to allow questions about recommending books directly connected to software development.
The way I see this now (pros and cons)
Pros:
- allow more questions that help software developers
Cons:
- tend to be open-ended, unless there is not a vast domain (e.g. Java development)
- tend to be opinion based
What do you think? Should we allow such questions?
I respect Alexei for opening a discussion on this, and Lundin for providing hard-won real world experience. I would lik …
2y ago
Are we talking about questions asking for book recommendations, or for a way to share/compile book recommendations? A q …
2y ago
As someone who spent a lot of time trying to get this to work on Stack Overflow, I would advise against it. Some …
1y ago
Are books special? When I see a question like this, I naturally transform it into a more general question about resou …
1y ago
Disclaimer: I am new here, I have not understood the overall policy of the site (yet), I can offer no moderator perspect …
2y ago
>To be a "better" site with helping people learn and grow and figure things out for themselves (instead of only giving t …
2y ago
Here is a slightly different suggestion, that may avoid the problems with open ended book recommendations. Book lists …
2y ago
Post
Are we talking about questions asking for book recommendations, or for a way to share/compile book recommendations? A question doesn't have to be the vehicle for the latter.
A question like "what are the best C++ books?" is likely to yield results that are haphazard and hard to manage. It would probably be more productive to focus on questions of the form "I want to learn more about X and have the following background and constraints; what is a good resource for self-study?". Notice what I did there: it's not a general-recommendation question, it's not meant to be the place for a whole topic, and it calls for context. (This is the approach that the "(something) Recommendations" sites on SE use.) This means we might end up with a bunch of questions about the same general topic, but approached from different angles. It seems like, with proper tagging, that could work, especially if these questions are in their own category.
But if the goal is to share knowledge, not ask a question (what I gather happened on SO, though I wasn't there), the community could instead use articles -- either general resources like Languages & Linguistics is doing, or a blog where a single author writes an article and there can be multiple articles on the same general topic. It sounds like you're not looking for the general-resources approach of L&L, but a blog approach could still work. You can set rules for blog posts, and community voting would provide signal.
0 comment threads