Welcome to Software Development on Codidact!
Will you help us build our independent community of developers helping developers? We're small and trying to grow. We welcome questions about all aspects of software development, from design to code to QA and more. Got questions? Got answers? Got code you'd like someone to review? Please join us.
Continuously read from piped input using Vim
In Vim, it's possible to tell it to read from stdin instead of a file, by using vim -. This is so that you can pipe the output of one command into Vim, to view/edit it there.
The problem I'm facing is that Vim seems to wait until the pipe is closed before starting up and displaying anything. It sits there saying
Vim: Reading from stdin... until the piped command terminates. This can be a very long time, depending on the command!
Is there any way I can get Vim to instead start displaying immediately, and autoread as more data comes from the pipe?
My use case is trying to use Vim as a pager, so that I can have custom syntax highlighting and folding, for Git logs. My current attempts are failing because Vim waits until the entire log has been loaded before displaying anything at all.
2 answers
You are accessing this answer with a direct link, so it's being shown above all other answers regardless of its score. You can return to the normal view.
Maybe passing the piped results through tail first would partially work. Use tail with the -f flag so that tail will continuously its contents. Example:
<cmd> | tail -f | vim -
I think you would still need to tell vim to get updates from tail periodically with :e!
1 comment thread
Unfortunately I think the simple answer is that you cannot do what you want with standard Vim (or NeoVim, which I also tested — although NeoVim is slightly more convenient in that you don't need to give the - argument to read from stdin).
Vim, like most text editors, is designed with the fundamental assumption that it is operating on a buffer of known size, rather than a stream of data which could be infinite in length. Once the input data is read, it is not read again unless you explicitly request another read operation with :e or similar. Although you can make Vim behave a bit like a pager using the - option, it is not really intended to be a replacement for less — it's more like a shortcut for process > /tmp/somefile.txt; vim /tmp/somefile.txt
Presumably in theory there's nothing to stop somebody from producing a modified version of Vim which has more pager-like features, although they'd need to consider how operations like "Go to the 50% position" would work in a potentially-infinite data stream (would this need to read the whole stream in order to find the true 50% mark, or just jump to 50% of the currently known data?)
0 comment threads
2 comment threads